Lambusango Forest Projects

By 2004, Operation Wallacea biodiversity survey teams had identified the Lambusango forests in central Buton Island as of outstanding biodiversity importance with 21 new vertebrate species to science having been discovered together with strong populations of endangered Sulawesi species such as the anoa. However, the forests were under threat from illegal selective logging, hunting for the anoa and clearances around the edge to create more farmland.

In 2005 the Operation Wallacea Trust was awarded a $1 million GEF grant supervised by the World Bank to establish strong protection for the Lambusango forests. The Trust team implementing this project is based in Bau Bau. There are a number of key elements to the management programme including a novel approach to managing the forests using a Forum of local people with the forestry powers from both national and regional governments devolved to this Forum. The idea is that the best people to manage an area are those who live closest to it and are most affected by the management decisions.


Lambusango forest in central Buton Island showing the biological monitoring camps.
 

An anoa hunt seen in 2004 - Bruce Carlisle
The Forum is playing an important role in increasing transparency and community involvement in forest management, and is developing as an important pressure group as well as a strategic partner to local government for the implementation of good forest governance in Buton District. The Forum has facilitated the development of conservation village regulations or Perdes (Peraturan Desa) in three villages (Siontapina, Kakenauwe and Labuhandiri). 

A Forest Crime Unit Lambusango (FCUL) has been formed. The FCUL consists of informants, response units and journalist teams and has conducted regular joint patrols with government investigators, forest rangers and journalists. Some illegal timber has been confiscated (about 35 m3 per month). There has however, been a lack of follow-up legal actions from the legal authorities (police and/or district attorney). The FCUL is also assisting legal authorities to enforce forestry laws in forest investigation posts. Monitoring on transport routes out of the forest has suggested that illegal logging may be declining. Based on data collection conducted in two forest products investigation posts by Lambusango Project staff who manned the posts in September 2005 and during October – December 2006, reduced by 73% over that period. Data from the comparison of satellite images between 2004 and 2006 suggests that clear felling of the forest has mostly stopped. 

Hunting of anoa is perhaps the key concern of the Lambusango forest management project and it appears from interview data that anoa hunting has declined over the 2005 to 2006 period. In addition two books on the wildlife and the forests have been produced. Education, awareness and skills training elements of the project have included: production of posters, monthly bulletins and newsletters, story books for children, jungle training for senior high school students, essay competitions on environment for senior high school and installation of conservation campaign boards surrounding Lambusango forest.

In the long term though the only way to ensure that the local communities continue protecting the forests are to ensure there is a direct link between conservation of the forest and prosperity in the village. Research ecotourism such as that provided by Operation Wallacea provides substantial income to a limited number of communities, and the project has employed consultants to expand the ecotourism revenue outside the normal Operation Wallacea season. However, in order to impact each of the villages a revenue stream that is more widespread has to be developed (see Wildlife Conservation Products scheme below). Other products are also being developed for sale through a similar scheme. Contracted villages have also received help in agricultural diversification (e.g. ginger). There is also an intensive biological and economic monitoring programme being carried out as part of this programme and which is supplemented by the Operation Wallacea surveys and volunteer input during the July - August period each year. Regular updates on progress and newsletters with the project are provided.

At the mid-term of the project, the monitoring programmes are sufficient to assess 12 (63%) of the 19 performance criteria.  To improve this, additional surveys are planned for 2008. The Lambusango Project appears to be on target to achieve 5 of the 19 performance criteria.  These include levels of awareness about the forests in the wider community, forest cover, a decrease in selective logging, hunting and use of the forest as assessed from trails, no changes in bird communities and maintaining anoa populations.  11 of the performance criteria are data deficient and cannot be assessed either because additional surveys need to be completed (8) or because additional years of data are needed (3).  There are only 3 of the performance criteria that do not look like being achieved without a change in approach by the Lambusango Project and these are now being addressed. 

Wildlife Conservation Products scheme

One of the fastest ways to get additional income into remote rural communities is to use the Fair Trade scheme for marketing their existing products. However, whilst the Fair Trade system has many advantages for increasing incomes in communities in developing countries, the scheme was not developed with any specific conservation benefit in mind. The Rainforest Alliance has developed a similar scheme, which has additional restrictions on how the crops can be grown (non use of herbicides and pesticides). However, even this scheme does not link price to the wider conservation performance of the whole village. Indeed there is one village in the Cusuco National Park buffer zone at the Op Wall Honduras site, which has achieved Rainforest Alliance approved prices for its coffee products, yet this village is the one most involved with illegal hunting in the adjacent reserve!

To overcome this problem the Operation Wallacea Trust has developed a new scheme called Wildlife Conservation Products where communities can receive Fair Trade equivalent prices for their commodities only if they have signed one of these conservation agreements. If there is evidence that village members are continuing to hunt or log then the scheme is suspended until the community can exert the necessary pressure to prevent this activity. However, the payment of prices significantly above market rates in these communities provides a strong positive incentive for ensuring 'their' forest is protected.


The Trust has started the purchase of coffee and cashews from communities in the Indonesia and Honduras Op Wall sites. These products are being marketed as direct action to save populations of the anoa (a Sulawesi endemic dwarf buffalo) and Baird’s Tapir (a threatened Central American species). These are just the start of a range of products that could be supplied through this scheme and the role of the UK Trust is to develop the markets in Europe and North America for these products and to organise the marketing for the Wildlife Conservation Products scheme.